Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium vs Calphalon vs All Clad (Are Ninja Pots and Pans That Great?)

I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium is their newest and thickest cookware available. Not only does it use the patented Neverstick formula, but now the cookware is better than ever. However, you might be wondering how it compares with Ninja Food Neverstick Premium vs regular, and also how it compares against Calphalon or All Clad.

Today we’re going to compare Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium vs Calphalon vs All Clad to see which is best. We’ll compare these based on temperature safety, material, build quality, and if they are oven and dishwasher safe.

By the end of this, you’ll know exactly which cookware set is right for you.

Calphalon PremierNinja Foodi NeverStick PremiumAll Clad 3-Ply

What is Ninja Foodi Neverstick?

All Clad and Calphalon have been around for years and everyone knows about them. The same can’t be said for Ninja Neverstick. This is a relatively new product (especially the premium line), and many people want to know what it really is. Is Ninja Foodi Neverstick nonstick cookware? Or is it something else entirely?

Yes, Ninja Neverstick cookware is nonstick, but it’s not the regular nonstick coating you might be thinking of. Ninja decided to do something special with their cookware (which is no surprise, just look at the Ninja Foodi line).

Ninja cookware is made using plasma ceramic particles that are fused to the Ninja pots and pans at 30,000℉. Most other nonstick cookware fuses the coating at 900℉. The benefit of the higher temperature is that is makes the coating harder, ensures it never chips or flakes, and food NEVER sticks (hence the name).

Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium vs Regular

You know what makes Neverstick special, so what is the difference between Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium and regular? First off, let’s clear about questions about the coating. When it comes to Ninja Foodi Neverstick Regular vs Premium, they both use the exact same coating. It’s bonded the same way, it has the same superior nonstick abilities, and the coating will never chip or flake.

Ninja Foodi NeverStick C100Ninja Foodi NeverStick Premium

They’re also both dishwasher safe, oven safe up to 500℉, and have many of the same features. So, what’s the real difference? It’s in the thickness. Both of them use similar aluminum bases, but Ninja Neverstick C100 is 3.3mm while Ninja Neverstick Premium C300 is 4.5mm.

They also have different rim thicknesses. Ninja C100 has a 4mm rim while Ninja C300 has a 13mm rim.

What does that mean? Basically it boils down to Neverstick Premium being more durable, holding heat better, and lasting longer. However, if you want the same nonstick coating and similar durability for a lower cost, then Neverstick C100 works well with any kitchen.

Temperature

Now that you know the difference between Ninja Neverstick Premium vs regular, let’s start comparing Ninja vs Calphalon vs All Clad. The whole point of pots and pans is to get hot and cook our food. However, one of the best ways to compare cookware is to see how hot they can get without melting or warping.

Let’s first cover what type of heat sources these cookware sets are compatible with. All three work well with electric, gas, induction, and ceramic stoves, so you can use them nearly anywhere. All three of them are also oven safe, so that’s also not a concern.

But what is their max temperature? You’ll want to know this for broiler cooking or if you want a good char on your food.

The max temperature for each is:

  • Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium: 500℉
  • Calphalon Premier: 450℉
  • All Clad 3 Ply Bonded: 600℉

When it comes to Ninja Neverstick vs Calphalon Premier, they are pretty similar. Ninja comes out on top, but it’s not by a huge margin. However, in terms of Ninja Neverstick vs All Clad, All Clad is able to withstand 100 extra degrees with ease. If you’re curious about other Calphalon products, we did a review of the top 5 Calphalon sets.

If you want high-heat cooking, then All Clad is the way to go. If you’re looking to keep things at a more standard heat, then these three are fairly equal.

All Clad 3-Ply

Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium vs Calphalon vs All Clad: Material

It’s hard to make judgements based on material since every metal and coating has pros and cons. That said, you’re probably curious what these three cookware sets are made from. You want to ensure they are made from strong, durable materials that last a long time.

Ninja cookware is made from quality aluminum with a thick rim and base for fast heating, along with a somewhat thinner body for fast heat dispersal. As we stated above, the nonstick coating is made from superheated ceramic particles that will never chip.

Calphalon Premier uses 3 ply stainless steel construction. This means that it uses three layers of metal, but only two of them are stainless steel. The center core layer is made from aluminum. This is fairly common because stainless steel isn’t a great heat conductor, but aluminum heats quickly and this makes the cookware better overall.

All Clad Stainless Steel 3 Ply is exactly the same. It’s made primarily from stainless steel, but includes an aluminum core for better heating. However, when it comes to All Clad vs Calphalon, All Clad is somewhat thicker. This is what helps it stay safe at higher temperatures.

If you want nonstick cookware, then Ninja pots and pans are the way to go. If you want stainless steel, then choose between All Clad or Calphalon. We would say that All Clad is a little better, but both are great.

Ninja NeverStick Premium

Ninja Foodi Neverstick Premium vs All Clad vs Calphalon: Build Quality

How well are the pots and pans built, and do they make home cooking easy? We’ll say in general that all three are good, but let’s really look at them and see which is best.

The first thing you need to check is handles. Cheap cookware screws the handles into place. They should be fine for a while, but soon the screws will come loose and you’ll worry about the handle coming off.

What you want are riveted handles. These stay on forever. Thankfully, all three brands use riveted handles, so it doesn’t matter if you choose All Clad, Ninja, or Calphalon here.

Let’s look a little closer at the handles though. Especially those on the pots. You want somewhat larger handles because these are easier to hold. Small handles increase the odds of you dropping the pot or burning your hands.

Both All Clad and Calphalon have fairly standard handles, but Ninja pots have bigger handles that are easy to grip. This is great if the pot is full, or if you simply want a better grip.

Let’s also cover lids. There are two types of lids: transparent (made with glass) and metal lids that you can’t see through. Some people prefer one over the other. Personally, we think transparent is better. You want to see what’s going on without lifting the lid and letting out all the heat.

Both Ninja and Calphalon use transparent lids, but the All Clad set doesn’t. But, if you happen to like all metal lids, then All Clad is right for you in this regard.

Calphalon Premier

Oven and Dishwasher Safe

Washing all your pots and pans by hand is annoying, especially if you were cooking with thick sauces and now they’re stuck to the pan. A dishwasher can help, but not all pots and pans are dishwasher safe.

Stainless steel cookware is almost always dishwasher safe. Sometimes there are some scuff marks left, but nothing permanent or dangerous. But, nonstick cookware can be dicey in the dishwasher. Sometimes it’s good, other times it will destroy the coating.

It should be obvious that both Calphalon and All Clad, being stainless steel cookware, can easily go in the dishwasher. Is Ninja Food Neverstick dishwasher safe? Yes, it is. You can pop this in with all your other dishes and cookware for an easy clean up.

You probably also want to know if they are oven safe. We covered this above in the temperature section, but just in case you missed it, Calphalon, All Clad and Ninja Neverstick are oven safe.

We can’t find any distinctions between them in either being oven safe or dishwasher safe, so it’s a tie.

What’s the Difference?

So, what are the major differences between these three cookware sets? Let’s break it down.

In terms of Ninja Neverstick vs Calphalon and Ninja Neverstick vs All Clad, the biggest difference is the nonstick coating. Ninja promises that food will never stick to their cookware, and the coating will never chip. The handles on their pots are somewhat larger, the max temperature is a little better than Calphalon, and it has transparent lids unlike All Clad.

In terms of Calphalon vs All Clad, the differences are more subtle. These are both stainless steel sets made from with a similar 3-ply construction. All Clad has a better max temperature and the material is thicker, but All Clad includes glass lids and is more affordable.

Calphalon PremierNinja Foodi NeverStick PremiumAll Clad 3-Ply

Final Thoughts

Overall we think that Ninja Foodi Neverstick is one of the best cookware sets around. Not only is it non stick, which everyone loves, but it also withstands a high max temperature, is both oven and dishwasher safe, and comes with many great pots and pans. All Clad is also wonderful, but considerably expensive. It’s good for those who want professional cookware at home. If you want great cookware at a better price, then consider Calphalon.