Best Electric Griddle: Presto vs Bella vs Cuisinart

I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Electric griddles are great when you want to grill up some burgers, bacon, or steaks without turning the oven on. You can cook inside or outside and get the great grill flavor with ease. Today we’re looking into the electric griddle best brands to help you find the right griddle for your kitchen. We’re looking at electric griddle Presto vs Bella vs Cuisinart and showing you their pros and cons.

Don’t worry, by the end of this you’ll know exactly which model is right for you. We even included a handy electric griddle buying guide at the bottom to help you out.

Presto GriddleBella GriddleCuisinart Griddle
Best for: affordable and versatileBest for: unique materialsBest for: advanced cooking, precision

Presto Electric Griddle Pros and Cons

Presto creates a range of different products from air fryers and pressure cookers to coffee makers and dehydrators. One of their biggest product lines is, you guessed it, electric griddles. The Presto electric skillets are made from strong materials, heat up fast, and provide even cooking. Let’s look at the pros and cons.

Presto Pros

Presto grills tick all the right boxes if you’re looking for something that heats quickly and is easy to store. Most of these griddles have removable handles that allow you to fully immerse the griddle for easy cleaning. The flat products can be stored in any cabinet just like a sheet pan.

All of the Presto skillets are made with premium materials like aluminum and offer a nonstick surface for easy cooking. You also get a handy drip tray for collecting oil and grease.

Presto Cons

You may not notice it initially from the photos, but the electric griddle Presto models have a slight crisscross pattern that might look weird at first (especially on eggs and pancakes). Everything tastes great, but if appearances are important, then this pattern might look strange at first.

The griddles also have a tendency to discolor over time, especially if they aren’t cleaned and stored properly. Once again, this is more about appearance than functionality, so it shouldn’t be a major problem.

Recommended Models

Presto 22-Inch Electric Griddle Removable Handles

Presto 22-Inch Electric Griddle

The griddler features removable handles that easily slide off for simple cleaning and storage when you’re finished. The handles are plastic while the cooking surface is strong and lightweight aluminum.

Not only is cleaning easy, but this griddle heats up fast and stays hot for even cooking. Setting the temperature is easy and there is a removable drip tray that collects grease. When you’re all finished, the griddle stores easily in any kitchen cabinet.

Presto Liddle Griddle

Presto Liddle Griddle

Our Presto Liddle Griddle review found that this model is ideal for compact cooking, simple storage, and is perfect when you want a strong griddle that doesn’t need much space. Don’t let its 8.5”x10.5” size fool you. This is meant for serious cooking, so feel free to cook steak, burgers, and more.

The unit is submersible when you remove the heat control, and there’s a drip tray that collects any oil and grease. When space is at a premium, this griddle prevails.

Presto Ceramic 22-Inch Electric Griddle Removable Handles

Presto Ceramic Electric Griddle

This is very similar to the other Presto grill with removable handles. It has all the same features in terms of easy storage, being fully immersible when the handles and heat control are removed, and the aluminum heavy duty griddle. The only major difference is the ceramic coating.

This makes the griddle even more nonstick, which means every cooking session is easy regardless of whatever you’re making.

Bella Electric Griddle Pros and Cons

Bella Housewares makes many different products, but the Bella griddles are by far their most interesting units. They are made from superior materials like copper titanium and some are even reversible for more cooking surfaces. If you’re looking for a brand with numerous features and great materials, then try an electric Bella griddle.

Bella Pros

Bella electric griddles have large cooking surfaces so you can cook lots of burgers, pancakes, and more with ease. They also have an electric griddle with lid combo and a reversible griddle and grill model that allows you to flip between the two cooking surfaces.

In general, this brand is known for unique materials and great features. If you want something a little different that’s useful and very powerful, then Bella is your brand.

Bella Cons

While Bella skillets tend to be more durable, the problem is that they are also heavier than most other griddles. This might be a problem when you want to travel really light, but it’s not a massive problem.

The temperature is sometimes a little off. It will often cook a little cooler than expected, so you might need to turn the heat up slightly. Try a test run before using this seriously so that you can get accustomed to how it works.

Recommended Models

Bella Copper Titanium Nonstick Electric Griddle

Bella Copper Titanium Griddle

The Bella electric griddles don’t fool around. This large 10.5”x20” griddle is made from copper titanium. It looks great and heats up fast and evenly, ensuring great cooking whether you’re making breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Despite reaching high temperatures, the handles stay cool. The griddle has ledges for easy pancake and burger flipping.

If you want a griddle that heats up 30% faster than traditional materials, is nonstick and scratch resistant, and is extremely durable, then you just found the best electric griddle for your needs.

Bella 12×12 Electric Skillet with Lid

Bella Electric Skillet with Lid

This is a combination skillet and griddle with lid. The cast aluminum base is both lightweight and durable, while the copper cooking surface heats quickly and evenly. Unlike many other griddles, this one comes with a dishwasher safe lid crafted from tempered glass. The cool-touch handles ensure you can easily move the griddle even right after cooking.

You’ll find the copper is both nonstick and more durable than other materials. If you want a model that heats quickly and can make whatever griddle recipe you’re looking for, then Bella has you covered.

Bella Ceramic Family Griddle

Bella Ceramic Electric Griddle

This is nearly identical to the Bella copper 10.5” x 20” griddle covered above, but the griddle is made with a ceramic coating instead of copper. Many people prefer ceramic and it has many of the same benefits as ceramic. It’s naturally nonstick, heats faster than traditional nonstick coatings, and is highly durable.

The large cooking surfaces makes this an ideal family griddle. It can cook up to 10 pancakes or eggs simultaneously. The handles stay cool the whole time and you can expect even cooking from the 1500 watts of power. Plus, the non-slip feet keep the griddle from moving.

Cuisinart Electric Griddle Pros and Cons

Cuisinart is one of those brands you see everywhere when it comes to kitchen appliances. You could literally fill your whole kitchen with their products and be happy. The Cuisinart electric griddle lineup takes the Instant Pot philosophy of adding as many appliances as possible into a single unit.

All of the Cuisinart griddlers offer numerous cooking surfaces, changeable plates, and various features that allow you to cook complex meals without needing another appliance.

Cuisinart Pros

The first thing you’ll notice is the folding design. This cooks your food from the top and bottom, so your meals are ready faster. Electric Cuisinart griddles all offer numerous features like doubling as a grill, panini press, and allowing you to split between half-griddle, half-grill.

They also have highly precise controls. You can easily set the right temperature, and whether you want to heat just half or all of the griddle surface.

Cuisinart Cons

Cuisinart skillets tend to have shorter cords, so you’ll have to be close to an outlet unless you’re willing to use an extension cord. They also tend to be least effective of the bunch when it comes to catching grease. Be careful when opening the griddle as some grease might come out.

These griddlers feel warm to the touch, especially when set to higher temperatures. Have an oven mitt ready if you’re cooking at 400 degrees.

Recommended Models

Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler

Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddle

If there was an Instant Pot griddler, then it would look like this. This is a top electric griddler that effectively combines a griddle, grill, and panini press into one. It comes with a large 11” x 9” cooking surface. This is enough for four burgers on each plate. You can choose to cook with the griddler open, or close it for even faster cooking.

The plates are removable for easy, dishwasher-safe cleaning. This allows you to swap between griddle, grill, panini, contact grill, or half-grill and half-griddle. The control knobs allow you to adjust the temperature and whether you want one or two plates to heat. On top of all this, you also get a drip trap for easy grease collection.

This is by far one of the best Cuisinart electric griddles and a top model in general.

Cuisinart Stainless Steel Electric Griddle with LCD Display

Cuisinart Stainless Steel Griddle

Looking for an even better Cuisinart electric griddle? This is much like the other 5-in-1 griddle above, but with one very big difference: an LCD display. It allows for even more precise temperature control and you can choose between 175-450 degrees. This is ideal for those who need precision cooking regardless of what they’re using. There’s also an integrated timer so you can walk away without worrying about your food burning.

This functions as a panini press, contact grill, full griddle, full grill, or half grill and griddle. Swap the plates and clean them in the dishwasher when you’re finished. All the plates are nonstick, and the drip tray will collect grease from burgers and steak. This is an advanced griddle you’re sure to love.

Cuisinart Griddler Elite 6-in-1 Deluxe

Cuisinart Elite Deluxe

Cuisinart takes the product even further with the Griddler Elite. This 6-in-1 model comes with the other features you’ve come to expect: panini press, contact grill, griddle, grill, and half griddle and grill. You also get a top melt option and one other huge feature: searing at 500 degrees. That’s right. This is an electric griddle that can sear.

You get a combination LCD screen and knob control to easily choose time, temperature, cooking zone, and more. The stainless steel housing is ready for long cooking sessions, and you can swap out the dishwasher-safe plates with ease. If you need the best of the best, then here it is.

The Best Electric Griddle

Which brand is the best? Let’s compare them side by side and see which is right for you.

Presto Electric Griddles

  • Presto vs Bella: easiest storage and cleaning, plus they heat somewhat faster
  • Presto vs Cuisinart: easier storage, cool to the touch, easier cleaning

Bella Electric Griddles

  • Bella vs Presto: offers reversible griddles, unique materials
  • Bella vs Cuisinart: unique materials, easier to store and clean

Cuisinart Electric Griddles

  • Cuisinart vs Presto: more features, faster cooking, precise settings
  • Cuisinart vs Bella: more features, faster cooking, precision cooking

Final Thoughts

So, which electric griddle is best? Presto electric griddles are best for basic cooking and storage, Bella electric griddles are a great middleground with more features and unique materials, and Cuisinart is the most advanced with numerous plates, precise controls, and faster cooking.

They’re all great and it depends on what you’re looking for. Just consider your needs and the right griddler should be easy to choose.

Electric Griddle Buying Guide

  • Size: while a griddle won’t replace your stove, it should be large enough to cook all the food you want in just one or two sessions
  • Material: most griddles get pretty hot, up to around 350-400 degrees, so you want a strong material that can withstand the heat without melting over time
  • Features: a basic griddle is great, but don’t you want something with more features? Some common features include other plates, precision controls, removable handles, and LCD screens
  • Cleaning: choose a model that’s easy to clean, otherwise it will be a pain whenever you’re finished using it
  • Storage: the griddle has to go somewhere. Make sure you have enough room to store the griddle and consider any features it has that makes storage easier

Electric Griddle FAQ

How to Clean Electric Griddle?

It’s easy in most cases. You can usually remove the griddle plate itself and then submerge it in warm water and soap. If the plate cannot be removed, then unplug the model, make sure it’s cool, and use either a sponge or wet towel to clean it off.

What to Cook on Electric Griddle?

Burgers are the de facto griddle food, but you can also cook eggs, bacon, sausage, pancakes, hotdogs, steaks, chicken, and more. Anything that cooks well on a stovetop cooks well in a griddle.

How to Use Electric Griddle?

While it depends on the exact model, most griddlers are the same. Plug it into an available outlet and turn up the heat to your desired temperature. Wait until it heats up (shouldn’t take longer than a minute or so) and then start cooking.