I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Thinking about making soft-serve ice cream at home but can’t decide between the Cuisinart Soft Serve and the Ninja Swirl?
Yeah, I’ve been there—debating between convenience, texture, and customization.
Here’s the real question:
- Which machine makes creamier soft-serve?
- Is one easier to use and clean?
- And what about that Ninja Creami everyone talks about?
Let’s break it all down so you can pick the right one with our Cuisinart Soft Serve vs Ninja Swirl review.
Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
 |  | |
Ice Cream Type | Soft-serve | Creamy soft-serve |
Process | Churns and freezes simultaneously | Mixes and freezes simultaneously |
Texture | Light, airy | Creamier, denser |
Topping Dispensers | Yes, built-in | No |
Dispensing Spout | Yes | No |
Non-Dairy Options | Yes | Yes |
Cleaning | More parts, takes longer | Fewer parts, easier to clean |
Capacity | Larger | Smaller |
Customization | Limited to built-in dispensers | Mix-ins can be added manually |
Price |  | |
How They Make Ice Cream
Both machines whip up soft-serve, but the process is different.
- Cuisinart Soft Serve: Works like a traditional ice cream maker—churning ingredients while freezing them. Plus, it dispenses soft-serve straight into your cone, complete with mix-ins if you want.
- Ninja Swirl: Freezes and mixes ingredients simultaneously, giving you soft-serve in minutes. There’s no dispensing function, but you get that classic creamy texture.
If you want that real soft-serve experience—complete with cones and toppings—Cuisinart wins. But if you’re after quick, simple soft-serve, Ninja Swirl is faster and easier.
Texture and Flavor: Cuisinart Soft Serve vs Ninja Swirl
The whole point of making ice cream at home? Nailing that creamy texture.
- Cuisinart Soft Serve: Smooth, airy, and light—just like what you’d get at an ice cream stand. It’s perfect for classic vanilla, chocolate, or swirl.
- Ninja Swirl: Creamier and denser, with a texture closer to soft-serve from a high-end dessert shop. Plus, you can use dairy or non-dairy ingredients without sacrificing creaminess.
If you’re craving that authentic soft-serve vibe, go with Cuisinart. But if you want something creamier and richer, Ninja Swirl takes the win.
Ease of Use and Cleaning: Ninja Swirl vs Cuisinart Soft Serve
Nobody wants a machine that’s a hassle to clean—especially when you’re craving ice cream.
- Cuisinart Soft Serve: More parts to clean, including the mixing arm, freezer bowl, and dispensing spout. It’s easy once you get the hang of it, but there’s a learning curve.
- Ninja Swirl: Fewer parts and a simpler design, making it quicker and easier to clean. Just rinse the bowl and paddle, and you’re done.
If you want quick and easy cleanup, Ninja Swirl is faster. But if you love the soft-serve experience with cones and toppings, Cuisinart is worth the extra effort.
Pros and Cons
Cuisinart Soft Serve
✅ Classic soft-serve texture
✅ Dispenses ice cream directly into cones
✅ Built-in topping dispensers
✅ Works with dairy and non-dairy ingredients
❌ More parts to clean
❌ Longer prep time (pre-freezing required)
Ninja Swirl
✅ Creamier, denser texture
✅ Simple design, easy to use
✅ Quick and easy cleanup
✅ Works with dairy, non-dairy, and fruit-based recipes
❌ No dispensing spout or topping dispensers
❌ Smaller capacity compared to Cuisinart
Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| | |
Ice Cream Type | Soft-serve | Creamy soft-serve |
Process | Churns and freezes simultaneously | Mixes and freezes simultaneously |
Texture | Light, airy | Creamier, denser |
Topping Dispensers | Yes, built-in | No |
Dispensing Spout | Yes | No |
Non-Dairy Options | Yes | Yes |
Cleaning | More parts, takes longer | Fewer parts, easier to clean |
Capacity | Larger | Smaller |
Customization | Limited to built-in dispensers | Mix-ins can be added manually |
Price | | |
Cuisinart Soft Serve vs Ninja Creami: How Are They Different?
Wondering how the Cuisinart Soft Serve compares to the Ninja Creami?
Here’s the scoop:
- Cuisinart Soft Serve: Designed specifically for soft-serve ice cream. It churns and freezes simultaneously, so you get that airy, light texture. Plus, it dispenses ice cream right into your cone—just like at an ice cream shop.
- Ninja Creami: A more versatile machine that works differently. You freeze your mixture overnight in pints, then the Creami processes it into ice cream, gelato, or sorbet. The texture is denser and richer—closer to premium ice cream than soft-serve.
Bottom line:
- If you want soft-serve with that classic swirl, choose Cuisinart.
- If you prefer richer, customizable ice cream, go with Ninja Creami.
Major Differences
- Process: Cuisinart churns and freezes simultaneously. Ninja Swirl mixes and freezes at the same time but is faster.
- Texture: Cuisinart is light and airy. Ninja Swirl is creamier and denser.
- Customization: Cuisinart has built-in topping dispensers. Ninja Swirl lets you mix in ingredients but no dispensers.
- Ease of Use: Ninja Swirl is simpler and faster to clean. Cuisinart has more parts but delivers that authentic soft-serve experience.
If you’re after quick, creamy treats, go with Ninja Swirl. But if you want that classic soft-serve vibe—cones, toppings, and all—Cuisinart Soft Serve is the winner.
FAQs
Can I use the Cuisinart Soft Serve to make dairy-free ice cream?
Yes! You can use almond milk, coconut milk, or oat milk to make dairy-free soft-serve.
Is Ninja Swirl faster than Cuisinart?
Yep. Ninja Swirl is quicker since it mixes and freezes simultaneously. Cuisinart takes longer because you need to pre-freeze the bowl.
Does Ninja Swirl have a dispensing spout?
Nope. Unlike Cuisinart, Ninja Swirl doesn’t dispense ice cream—you scoop it out manually.
Which one is easier to clean?
Ninja Swirl is faster to clean because it has fewer parts. Cuisinart has more components, like the mixing arm and spout, but it’s still pretty straightforward.
How does Ninja Creami compare to Cuisinart Soft Serve?
They’re totally different. Cuisinart Soft Serve makes light, airy soft-serve, while Ninja Creami creates denser, richer ice cream. If you’re after classic soft-serve cones, go with Cuisinart.
Other Interesting Articles
- KitchenAid Grain and Rice Cooker vs Cuisinart Rice Cooker: Which Should You Choose?
- KitchenAid Grain and Rice Cooker vs Aroma Rice Cooker: Which One’s Right for You?
- KitchenAid Grain and Rice Cooker vs Zojirushi: Which One’s Worth It?
- Flavortown vs GreenPan: Which Cookware Reigns Supreme?
- Flavortown Laser Titanium 12-Piece Cookware Set: Worth the Splurge?
Author
This article was written by HappyFoodGeek, your kitchen gadget expert. Whether it’s ice cream makers, rice cookers, or cookware, we break down the pros and cons so you can make the best choice for your kitchen.