Ninja Creami vs Breville (Best Value Home Ice Cream Maker)

I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Finding the right ice cream machine can be tough, especially because there are so many options. Today our Ninja Creami vs Breville Smart Scoop review will compare these to see which is the best ice cream maker for hard ice cream and for home use. It’s a tough battle, but one is better than the other.

Our Breville Smart Scoop vs Ninja Creami review will compare these based on overall features, settings, capacity, freezing type, and any other differences we can find.

Read on to see which is right for you. While we think that Ninja Creami is best for most people, you get more options along with an active compressor with Breville Smart Scoop. It’s the more expensive option though, which is why we think Creami will be better for most people.

Ninja CreamiBreville Smart Scoop

Breville vs Ninja Creami: Features

What features are best with ice cream makers? Each unit seems to have its own set of features and we want you to know exactly what you’re getting. These sections will show you the overall features you get, but continue to read on to get more specific information.

What Features Does Ninja Creami Have?

Ninja Creami has many amazing features. This comes with 7 one-touch programs for ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and more. You’ll have no problem getting the right consistency, especially with the Creamify technology that blends and smoothens all the ingredients into the perfect frozen treat.

Another unique benefit would be the personal pint containers. As with many other Ninja appliances, the blending cup is also used for serving. You get two personal pints. Simply place your ingredients in the containers, freeze them, and then use the Creami ice cream blender to turn it into a frozen dessert. This lets you make two distinct flavors with ease.

All parts are dishwasher safe, and it’s easy to add mix-ins after the ice cream is finished. You’ll find that this is a highly convenient and powerful ice cream maker for home use.

Check Price: Ninja Creami ->

What Features Does Breville Smart Scoop Have?

What do you get with the Breville Smart Scoop? This is like having a professional ice cream machine in your home. This is an ice cream maker with compressor, which means that it freezes the ingredients by itself. Many people find this convenient, and it also ensures that your ingredients remain the perfect temperature.

Another fantastic benefit is that you get 12 hardness settings. From frozen yogurt and soft serve to firmer forms of ice cream, this is ideal for those who want precise control over the ice cream texture. Those who truly love either soft or hard ice cream may prefer this machine due to this firmness settings.

It also comes with a timer that shows you how much longer until your perfect homemade ice cream is done, and there’s a little hatch for adding mix-ins near the end of the cycle.

Check Price: Breville Smart Scoop ->

Breville Smart Scoop vs Ninja Creami: Settings

Both offer you a good number of settings, but Breville ice cream maker with compressor comes with nearly double the settings of Ninja Creami. This makes it ideal for those who love controlling the firmness of their ice cream.

Ninja Creami comes with 7 settings for ice cream, gelato, sorbet, lite ice cream, milkshake, smoothies, and then for mix-ins. That last setting is for blending in mix-in additions, so there’s really 6 firmness settings to choose from. That’s actually very good and it beats out many other home ice cream machines, but not Breville.

Smart Scoop by Breville hits back hard with 12 firmness settings. This allows you to choose settings for gelato, sorbets, frozen yogurt, soft serve, firm ice cream, and more. Plus, you can choose if you want your frozen treat harder or softer with the right selection. There is a dial that allows you to choose the exact firmness.

Both are good, but Breville wins here as it gives you double the options.

Ninja CreamiBreville Smart Scoop

Ninja Creami vs Breville: Capacity

This one is a little tricky because Breville offers a larger capacity, but many people will like how Ninja easily separates its capacity. Let’s take a look to see which is right for you.

The capacity you get with each is:

  • Ninja Creami capacity: 1 quart (separated as 2 pint containers)
  • Breville Smart Scoop capacity: 1.5 quarts

There are a few things to note here. First of all, Breville makes more ice cream overall. However, you can only make one flavor at a time. While the Ninja containers are smaller, they are self-contained. This means that you can quickly make chocolate ice cream in one and then strawberry in another without the two ever touching.

Another thing to consider is that Ninja’s capacity is only limited by the containers. By default, you get two containers here. However, you can buy additional containers and significantly increase the capacity. You can’t do that with Breville. At the same time, you still need to make each pint individually.

If you will be making one flavor at a time, then Breville is better. If you want to make numerous flavors, then Ninja is a little faster though the capacity is smaller for each container.

Check Price: Ninja Creami ->

Ninja Creami vs Breville Smart Scoop: Freezing Type

Many people who get their first home ice cream machine expect it to freeze the ingredients, but this often isn’t the case. There are both active freezing and passive freezing machines. Active ones are ice cream machines with compressors that can freeze the ingredients. Passive means you need to pop the ice cream ingredients into your freezer. The machine will then churn them into frozen treats.

Ninja Creami doesn’t have a compressor, which means that it can’t freeze ingredients itself. You will have to load the ingredients into the container and then pop that in the freezer. It’s easy enough, but it takes time for them to be ready for churning.

Breville Smart Scoop has a compressor, which means it freezes the ingredients itself. You can choose to pre-freeze so you can churn later, or you can choose to have everything done at once. It can also keep ice cream frozen for up to 3 hours.

Both are good, but we have to say that having a compressor is better. Breville wins here, but you can save a good amount of money by choosing Ninja Creami and freezing the ingredients in your freezer.

Check Price: Breville Smart Scoop ->

What is the Difference Between Ninja Creami and Breville Smart Scoop?

Curious about what is the difference between Breville Smart Scoop and Ninja Creami? These are actually two very different ice cream machines that serve different needs. Finding the right one for you depends on how much ice cream you want, how much control you want over firmness, and other factors.

Ninja Creami is better for those who want to make numerous flavors or who only want to make a pint at a time. The blending itself is faster, but you will have to place the container in the freezer first. While it has a good number of settings, it doesn’t have quite as many as Breville.

Breville Smart Scoop is the more expensive of the two, but it comes with double the settings, a larger capacity, and it can freeze the ingredients itself. This makes it like a professional ice cream maker at home with a compressor, which is truly amazing.

Ninja CreamiBreville Smart Scoop

Final Thoughts

If you want more control over the firmness or to have an ice cream machine that freezes ingredients, then Breville Smart Scoop is right for you. However, Ninja Creami is at a better price and it might be better for those who love making many different flavors at once.

Leave a Comment